User interviews aren’t exactly the most natural interaction. You’ve called in someone — typically a total stranger — to sit with you for anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour and answer questions. Chances are you aren’t an expert interviewer like Barbara Walters or Oprah. So how do you draw out the best material? What do you do if an interviewee is cold and untalkative? What if the responses are wildly different than expected and knock your plan off-course? What if you didn’t even have a plan?
Nicola Rushton has faced all of the above over the course of her UX/UI career and lived to tell the tale. She’s previously served in senior product design roles for Pivotal Labs, which counts among its clients GE, Citi and Mercedes-Benz, and co-founded the retrospectives tool Postfacto. She now consults for later-stage companies as well as emerging startups on user research and product design. Nicola’s especially known for her thoughtful writing on user research.
We wanted to tap Nicola’s best tips and tactics for a productive user interview, so Nicola agreed to conduct a 20-minute user interview on me and talk me through her tactics. As a relative newcomer to user research, I was thrilled to have the opportunity to learn from one of the best in the business. Here’s what I learned.
First, the basics. Nicola prepped a bunch of material before our call. She settled on doing a generative interview, a style of questioning that’s meant to help generate ideas, rather than test them.
Here’s what she suggests doing beforehand to set yourself up for success:
1. Make a moderator guide. This document will contain your mission and learning goals. Her guide included her mission, learning goals and a list of her questions. In some cases she wrote a script for exactly how to word her introduction and question.
2. Start with a thesis... Nicola’s hypothesis was that freelance writers experience pains around marketing their services.
3. ...but prepare to be wrong. Even if you have a well-formulated guess about what the user will say, you’ll never know with 100% accuracy. And surprise answers are often the best part — they guide you to the pain points and insights that’ll inform a better product.So be mentally prepared to shift gears when needed.
4. Book one hour if possible. Nicola and I had only 20 minutes together, but at minimum, a half-hour to an hour is ideal. But if the interviewee seems to be getting tired, she wraps it up at 45 minutes. Reading the room and rolling with the punches is a big part of successful interviewing.
5. Talk to at least five people. This piece of advice has itself been tested. “Beyond five, your return on investment is usually lowered. Five is enough for synthesis. It’s small and it’s affordable in both time and money spent,” Nicola says.
Want more content like this?
Sign up to get our weekly newsletter
+ a PDF copy of this report.
Iris is a freelance journalist and writer online. I want to make a product for online writers and I'm doing early generative research. My first step is to really understand my users: online writers. What are my assumptions about them, and am I correct?
1. Understand context. Where, what, when, for whom, do writers write?
2. Understand tools. How do writers create their content? Dig into what tools are used, why, and what the biggest pains are there.
3. Find their pain points.
With all those pieces in place, and maybe a colleague in the room to take notes, she dives into the interview. Here’s how she approached our call:
Nicola opened our interview with a bright “Hi!” and asked me about the time and weather in San Francisco. She also told me a little bit about her day. We bantered for a minute or two before diving in. It made me like Nicola, and it felt almost as if we were friends chatting. That’s the feeling you should aim for, Nicola says.
Nicola uses this phrase in every single user interview she does: “The plan for today is we have about [X] minutes, right?” “It’s really important to give them context of what’s going on, and timeboxing so they know you won’t be chatting forever,” she says. Nicola explained that her team was building a product for writers and that their process included speaking to potential future users, then asked if I had any questions before we got started.
Imagine a movie where the camera first pans over a city before zooming in on a house or person. Take the same approach to your interviews — create a foundational understanding of the person before honing in on specifics like pain points. Nicola kicked off with: “Maybe you can tell me a little bit about yourself. What do you do for work?” She followed that up with “How many writing projects do you have in the next week and a half?” She asked me to describe what I was working on currently. This, combined with Nicola’s friendly and curious attitude, slowly warmed me up to talking about myself and my work. Most people aren’t used to talking extensively about themselves with a total stranger, so be mindful of building the up, Nicola says.
Once you’ve laid the groundwork, here’s where you can start looking for pain points. Push them a bit on details, and don’t be afraid to ask follow-up questions, or even the same question worded differently. Nicola said, “Can you think of a recent project that you've done and just talk me through what does that actually look like? Take me step by step, even if they're really sort of little boring things.
Nicola wrote down and starred my comments when they struck her as interesting. As it turns out, her original thesis was wrong—which isn’t uncommon. “It didn’t seem that marketing was a big pain for you,” she says. After asking me a few questions about marketing and listening to my answers, she changed course.
“I did a lot of interviews before coming to this one specific phrase. I found that things could get kind of awkward at the end. How do you finish up? You’ve built up and built up, you’re having a really good conversation, people are really talking to you about themselves. Then time is up. Ok well, we’re done! It’s a bit awkward. So I say, ‘I just have one last question before we wrap up,’” Nicola says. “It’s really good because they know it’s about to be finished. You get them into that moment where the cameras stop rolling. Quite often, you close the book and stand up, then they stand up and turn to you and say, ‘Oh, also, gotta tell you that…’ Often what they say after the interview is over is really interesting.”
Nicola works to draw enthusiasm out from interviewees who are less than excited to be there. “The only other time people get interviewed is when they’re trying to get a job. Naturally people feel awkward. When this happens, I change track to get some measure of enthusiasm. Don’t go entirely off-topic — it creeps them out. But try questions like: ‘Tell me about your family. Who do you live with? What’s the last thing you watched on TV? What are your hobbies? What games do you play?’ Then pick up on whatever they say that they seem excited about, and chat about it for awhile,” Nicola says. “That’s a trick to help people open up a bit. And consider pulling back the curtain a little bit. I get vulnerable myself and tell them that we don’t know whether the work we’ve done is good enough.”
“I keep in mind the top three things I listed in my guide: understand a writer’s context, tools and pain points. It’s top of mind at all times, especially pain points,” Nicola says.
Nicola used the phrase “So, to play it back to you…” a few times and would repeat what I’d just said. It helps confirm that you have the right understanding. To do this, make note of specific phrases the user is saying. “The notes are most important for me to look back on while I'm talking, to use the same phrases you used and ask relevant questions. I'll often jot down my next questions while the participant is talking,” Nicola says.
Nicola kept her tone light and friendly throughout our call. She seemed genuinely interested and curious about my work, and soon, I found myself blathering away. Nicola didn’t interrupt me much if at all — and the more I talked, the more valuable takeaways Nicola got. “I love to get people to tell me stories,” she says. “A really big part of being a product designer is to really understand the person by talking to them, and that means speaking to them on your level.”
Even though the time was less than ideal at just 20 minutes, Nicola managed to get a ton of information out of me. After quickly learning that her original thesis around marketing pain points was wrong, she asked me, “What’s preventing you from being as successful as you want to be?” It was a pretty personal question, and wouldn’t have worked as well had she not built a rapport with me and built up to that moment by asking me about how I built my writing business and what tools I use to craft articles.
By the end of the interview, Nicola had struck gold. I told her it’d be nice to have an assistant to set up some of the raw material I use for writing — cleaning up interview notes, suggesting an outline, crafting summaries, transcribing audio or video.
“That’s what you really want to talk about as a product designer. You told me the exact work you don’t want to do, but have to do. All of those things sounded to me like they could be potentially provided by a service or product,” Nicola says.
From that 20 minutes, Nicola was able to glean enough for a product idea. “I have enough to create some sort of product, perhaps one that starts by machine learning to pull out interesting topics from automatically transcribed audio,” she says. “Hopefully at this point I’ve heard similar things from the handful of other writers I’ve interviewed.”
Nicola’s next steps would be to chat to four or five people total — other content creators, strategists and online writers, hopefully the same day or next day. “You want to create something quickly. By next week I’d want a mockup to show people, and it goes on from there. Keep iterating, 100% as quickly as possible. It’s so much better to create the quickest possible prototype. Super quick and dirty, draw it on paper if you have to,” Nicola says.
In conclusion, Nicola urges interviewers to consider users as if they are friends. “Try to think of each user as a new friend, and you want to learn about them. Don’t get nervous — relax! It’s just nice to create the sense that you’re having a conversation with someone. You’re listening to what they’re saying and flowing with what they say, not just reading a list of questions.”
Want to contribute to User Interviews content? Here’s how.
Get "Fresh Views," our weekly newsletter, delivered to your inbox. We feature interviews and point-of-views from UXers, product managers, and research nerds of all stripes.Subscribe
Make smarter business decisions with this guide to plan and execute effective customer interviews. Turn feedback into business growth.
User testing is fun, informative, and impactful. User Test Fest is here to prove it.